What a delight! I really didn't expect to laugh so much - all the 'working class' characters had razor-sharp humour through their dialogue. The lead parts highlighted the innocence of the age, the passion was a simmering undercurrent.. Even so I found there was a realism which is often lacking in modern cinema - for example the actors' teeth were as nature intended, not white and straight! As a snapshot of the constraints of middle-class post-war life, I found it fascinating.
What used to be a model of middle class Englishness now seems a very strange place indeed. Yet the film remains a widely loved tale of unrequited love. A heartbreaker. Celia Johnson and Trevor Howard are married, but not to each other. They fall deeply in love after a chance meeting at a provincial railway station, but separate because it is the right thing to do...
It's a slight story given depth by the use of Rachmaninoff on the soundtrack and Robert Krasker's truly exceptional images of romance among the steam engines. It is beautifully edited too. But what we most remember the film for are the performances of the two stars as the reserved, scrupulous strangers. This was Howard's big break and he is haunting, but it's Celia Johnson who brings the tears.
It now feels like a remembrance of the bourgeois emotions- forbearance, shame, decency... The couple are paralysed by convention. It was loosely adapted from a play by Noël Coward and a popular analysis is that the gay playwright used a female character as a stand-in for a sexually conflicted man who is tempted from his marriage into an affair with another male... And that interpretation is a good fit.
So while orthodox, it is also ambiguous. After WWII the theme of sacrifice must have felt close to home. Especially when Celia's stolid husband (Cyril Raymond) famously, and kindly says, 'Thank you for coming back to me'. They will live until death with the unspoken trauma of her experience. But now it feels the message is the opposite; that life is short and happiness is fragile, so take love gladly, however it comes.