Breaking the Code of Silence
- By the Grace of God review by CP Customer
A very thoughtful film covering the breaking of the code of silence that had shrouded the Catholic Church for years with regard to illegal sex with under aged boys. Very thoughtfully told, but at the same getting the message across of what actually was happening, and how a group of victims got together to expose the scandal and rock the Catholic Church.
5 out of 5 members found this review helpful.
Thoughtful but limited exploration of abuse
- By the Grace of God review by JB
The great, prolific and incredibly versatile writer director Francois Ozon turns his attention to the real life case of Father Bernard Preynat, a Catholic priest who is accused of sexually assaulting countless young boys from the 1980s onwards. And, what's more, the Church has known about it for years.
By the Grace of God has an almost episodic structure: it starts with the case of Alexandre (Melvil Poupaud) a family man living in Lyon, and still a practicing Catholic. He goes to the church to seek some sort of closure after he's ready to talk about the assault he suffered from Preynat. At the same time, in other parts of the country, two very different and separate men are starting to come forward including Francois (Denis Menochet) and Emmanuel (Swann Arlaud). They join up forces, after conversations with the church break down, to seek justice.
There are obvious comparisons with the movie Spotlight, covering a similar topic but in the US. However, that had a narrative focus and tension, driven by the investigative journalist team at the centre of the story, that this movie arguably lacks especially with its open ended conclusion (that has now been resolved). But this movie works better on a human level, as we're much closer to the victims here and we can see how the emotional, psychological, physical and even spiritual aftermath of the abuse manifests in very different ways.
I did wonder whether the stories would have worked better as a longer form TV mini series than a two hour film. Ozon clearly and rightly wants to unpick the ongoing human consequences of historic abuse. But by cramming three very different stories in one movie, he is perhaps doing a disservice to each one. His fractured narrative presentation does not help either. A thoughtful and thought provoking film for sure, but not an entirely successful one.
2 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
Authentically appalling
- By the Grace of God review by JT
French drama schools must be very different from British or American ones. This film has the ring of truth throughout and not a whiff of "people doing acting" which makes its bleak message all the more awful. The fact that neither of the main perpetrators was ever punished must leave the complainants feeling pretty sick. I will make a point now of watching Spotlight, which I gather tells a similar story of abuse and cover-up by the church hierarchy.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Excellent docudrama
- By the Grace of God review by BS
Excellent docudrama on a difficult subject. Very well presented and affecting. Never an easy subject to approach but done well here. Recommend.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.
Maybe you need to be Catholic
- By the Grace of God review by CP Customer
This was an interesting film about historic child abuse in the Catholic church, specifically the French Catholic church.
The focus was on the victim's attempts to reconcile their personal experience with their faith.
It also set out the Church's response, to look after and forgive the perpetrator.
However, for those of us who are not Catholic, the film is interesting for what it did not cover: the legal or state's response, the lack of child focus of state and Church, the lack of consequences for actions, the lack of lessons learned.
As a non Catholic, I couldn't fathom why. Maybe you need to be Catholic to to understand that.
0 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
A powerful, shocking & quietly hopeful story of exposing horrific historic crimes
- By the Grace of God review by Timmy B
When Spotlight was released & went on to Oscar glory, it reinvigorated the investigative drama and proved beyond a doubt that you don't have to send actors running down corridors to create tension, simply give them an excellent script/story & brilliant direction. Spotlight's success also clearly influenced other films around that time, with mixed results. Somehow (and I still can't believe quite how they managed to do this,) Spielberg, Hanks & Streep made The Post one of the most boring films imaginable, despite the powerhouse of talent involved. But there was also a French film, from a very different director, which is brilliant.
François Ozon is in very different territory to his normal works. His previous film, L'Amant Double, was an erotic thriller which did not shy away from showing the more provocative & intimate scenes. Whereas in By the Grace of God, the sexual activity is associated with horrendous trauma, abuse & life-changing injuries.
The film is based on the crimes of French priest Bernard Preynat, although the other characters are based on composites of many of his victims. We follow Alexandre Guérin, a successful banker who on the surface has the life anyone would want (loving family, successful career, beautiful home, devout wife,) who discovers that Preynat, who was moved from the parish, is working with children again; François Debord, a medical professional who is far more volatile & reported the abuse to his parents, fracturing his family almost irreparably; and Emmanuel Thomassin, a haunted & horrifically mentally/physically scarred younger man, who unlike the previous 2 men, has had a life of disarray & addiction, as well as having multiple toxic relationships.
Like Spotlight, the film is crafted unbelievably carefully. Generous amounts of time & world-building are given to develop each of the characters, plus Preynat is also mercifully not turned into the caricature which so many writers might be tempted to go down (a demonic, almost pastiche-level evil being,) but as a pathetic & cornered old man whose protection from the Church has finally run out of road.
We watch as the 3 men, along with their families & eventually others who come forward, form their own group which they take public to force the Church to confront not only the rampant sexual abuse within their parishes, but also to properly punish the men committing these heinous acts and destroying multiple lives in the process. For me, I also welcomed the fact that these characters were sometimes challenging & abrasive, especially Debord.
The only real issue I have with this film is that towards the end, the story & narrative starts to falter, which is then compounded when it abruptly ends, with a quick epilogue about the court case. And it is a real shame. I felt like the film was in many ways rushed to completion, which just made it all the more frustrating, considering how for over two thirds of it, it was impeccable filmmaking.
But I still recommend it, for the performances, direction & script
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.