What is disappointing about this film is that in remaking the ground breaking BBC series of the 1980s director Martin Campbell lost all the essence, weight, ingenuity, subtlety and complexity of that's series to produce an average cop thriller that makes little sense.....and he directed both! The story here is very simple and ultimately clichéd as a revenge narrative where Boston detective Tom Craven hunts down the mysterious killers of his beloved daughter who was trying to uncover corruption at a nuclear storage facility. Throw is more bloodshed, take out the superb characterisations from Troy Kennedy Martin's original story and this is what you have left. Mel Gibson as Craven does his usual quivering in anger and tearful righteousness, Ray Winstone is underused and basically wasted, his role as a covert agent is eroded to almost nothing making his actions mostly pointless to the story. Campbell dips into some of the key narrative devices used to such great effect in the series and effectively renders them silly here. This is a poor film from a director who has done far better not only with the Edge Of Darkness series but of course his work in the James Bond series reboots. This is a big disappointment and one to avoid. Watch the series instead it's fantastic.
Very disappointed with this film. I had hoped for something like Conspiracy Theory and it starts promising but then does not follow through. I only gave the film 3 stars because Mel Gibson plays the lead role.
I saw this film a few years ago and wanted to review. Strangely in the second viewing I could not remember what happened next. I think it is because the plot is quite complex. Another reviewer has mentioned that Mel was not his best. Possibly so but there are no weak actors in the cast and many scenes are very tense and involving. I'm glad I saw it again.