Charming
- Not One Less review by JD
Given that the average age of the actors in this film is 8 it is quite watchable. An uplifting film portraying poverty in a positive way with a very friendly atmosphere in the remote and impoverished village contrasting with a busy, more affluent and crowded but nonetheless lonely existence in the city.
1 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
Outstanding.
- Not One Less review by CP Customer
An outstanding Chinese drama in which the entire cast is made up of amateurs playing characters which mirror their real life. The storyline is fantastic and kept me hooked from start to end. If you're a fan of foreign cinema then this should be high on your rental list.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Modern Day Propaganda?
- Not One Less review by JT
Fascinating tale of young teacher placed in a poverty-struck rural school, in fear of losing pupils
The story evolves and takes us into a modern Chinese city. Quite a contrast and shocking to see the conflicting standards. The film could be interpreted as a moral tale, or taken at face value? We werent too sure as a deeper understanding of the chinese psyche would be needed.
Fabulous cast of children who were totally captivating, and we love the insights into lives of others
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.
Extremely high quality acting from the young cast and direction from Zhang Yimou.
- Not One Less review by Piehawker
Another excellent drama from Zhang Yimou who gets fantastic and natural performances from the children. The film is emotional and dramatic, whilst any sense of sentimentality. There is some stunning cinematography and although the film doesn't having a driving propulsive narrative, I found it captivating.
There is a harsh and authentic look at rural schooling, the rationing of the chalk and a 13 year old being put in charge as a substitute, and the film doesn't shy away from the poverty and hardships. However there is a warmth and defiance in the spirits of the characters (especially Wei as a girl forced to grow up quickly when thrust into the city) and the ending was moving and emotional without being excessive or mawkish.
I've not seen a Zhang Yimou directed film that hasn't had an extremely high standard of craft and quality, and this definitely one of his lighter warmer films than say Shanghai Triad or Raise the Red Lantern which are masterpieces, but quite heavy and tonally grim. This has a more fairytale magical feel (which being very grounded and down to earth) with Wei almost on a small scale but significant heroes journey. Highly recommended.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.