The casting of this film is first class. Jean Dujardin fits the bill as the flakey hero Neuville and Melanie Laurent makes an excellent contrast with her keen-eyed, sharp-tongued Elisabeth who could have stepped out of a Jane Austen novel. The story is well told, with many moments of comic suspense and some wonderful, unexpected developments in the plot. The whole business of Elisabeth concocting a heroic military career for Neuville in order to console her despairing sister, and then having to deal with the real Neuville whose return means the end of her fictional hero, is a great comic scenario which the film skilfully mines for our entertainment. Everything about the film works as it should - the script is witty, the acting is colourful, the pace is brisk and the story is told with a deft lightness of touch. This is an amusing yarn to brighten any dull day. Highly recommended.
I would rate this 3 & a 1/2 out of 5. Any French comedy i usually enjoy & that was the case with this. It's lightly amusing all the way through & watchable .Well acted & overall i cannot fault anything.
We thoroughly enjoyed this film. Reminded me of Vanity Fair actually - a lot of tongue in cheek and anti-hero stuff. Most enjoyable, not violent and not depressing!