A prisoner of war comedy which was made before there was a tradition of POW films in Hollywood. Consequently there's a voice over at the start, explaining what a Stalag was and how the camps were run. It was written by a pair of former POWs. The plot now is familiar; one of the American captives is a spy giving information to the Germans.
Billy Wilder was a great blender of genres and as well as a comedy and a war film this works as a thriller. Who is the stoolie? Most of the captured flyers think it's the aloof JJ Sefton (William Holden) who trades goods with the enemy and finagles a few luxuries for himself. To protect himself from brutal reprisal, he must find the mole.
It's a very black comedy. Some of the men die because of the leak. Wilder implies these Americans are no better than any other men would be in these circumstances, and may have something to hide. There is humour but also a degree of realism; the camp is dirty, the prisoners are half crazy.
Holden is perfect as the supercilious Sefton. Though his Oscar was a bit of a push in an ensemble part. Sefton is an antihero and nearly all the characters are morally ambiguous. The most memorable performance is by Robert Strauss as 'Animal' who gives the film comic energy. WWII was still a recent trauma, but the public bought Wilder's comic cynicism.
I’m afraid we thought this film was rubbish. We made allowance for its age, but it didn’t take the situation in the POW camp seriously enough in our view. Tho we didn’t watch much of it I have to admit. Can’t think why I put It on our list.