Rent The Bourne Identity (2002)

Bourne for success? - The Bourne Identity review by CP Customer

Robert Ludlum is a master crafter of spy/espionage thrillers and indeed the premise of this movie seems promising at the start.

Matt Damon plays Jason Bourne, (or does he?) who is picked up floating in the ocean by a ship that somewhat conveniently is in the vicinity.

Our hero cannot remember who he is, why he'd been shot twice in the back, nevermind why he's floating in the sea like a sponge.

Still undaunted, Jason goes about finding out who he is and clues lead him to a railway station but the mystery only deepens as he discovers a gun, several passports bearing his face and over 20,000 US dollars in cash.

So who is he? What is he? A spy or something else? An assassin perhaps? And the other question is why is someone determined to kill him before he gets the answers?

Sounds like a sure fire winner here, BUT....

Damon gives a good, not a great, but good performance as the confused hero and his supporting actress also gives a good, not great performance. And that sums up the film.

Trailers may suggest it's a white knuckled rollercoaster ride, but it isn't. It has some nice action sequences and a very good car chase, but somehow it never seems to hit top gear or really balze towards the finish line after leaving the blocks. The sequel I've been told is better and I shall hold judgment on that until I've seen it. As for this one, not bad, not bad at all but I think an opportunity to really establish Matt Damon as an action hero was squandered. I've seen worse but I've seen better, James Bond he ain't!

A good start to the Bourne franchise, but this film still has its issues, despite some great action - The Bourne Identity review by TB

In many ways, Jason Bourne saved James Bond. Conceived very deliberately by both Robert Ludlum & the filmmakers as the anti-Bond, this series was designed to show espionage in a very real light. There were precious few gadgets to get you out of trouble, no supercars & if you were caught, you were disowned. Released the same year as the atrocious Die Another Day, this really turned the spy film genre on its head, forcing the 007 producers as well as other filmmakers to up their game.

But despite this monumental achievement, this film is for me only fairly average in many ways. The script is a bit too spare in many ways, as much as we are in the same position as Bourne, trying to work out what is happening. I also really disliked how it looked: limp, miserable, dank and colourless. Even the outside scenes are dreary. Again, I appreciate the point the filmmakers are trying to show: the grim & dark world of espionage. But they have gone far too far the other way.

The chemistry between Damon & Franka Potente (Marie) is also fairly terrible as well. When they first meet, they are both in a sense lost. As they brave danger together, you expect & see them get closer together. But I never was convinced about this element of the film, in this film. In Supremacy, their screen time & interactions are far more believable, which again I put at the feet of Paul Greengrass. Marie, despite Potente's best efforts, is mainly very annoying & grating. And as the film progresses, as much as she has some good moments, for me it is never what it could have been.

But there are some big positives to this film, starting with Damon. Apart from some small supporting parts in action films, most people knew him from dramas such as Talented Mr Ripley & Good Will Hunting. But he absolutely owns & is believable as Jason Bourne. It is clear he worked extensively with the stunts & never looks anything less than the spy Ludlum so clearly envisaged. The only outstanding performance comes from Chris Cooper as Conklin, Bourne's handler. Cooper is always exceptional in whatever he is in, and he dominates the screen here, every inch the burnt-out, cynical & devious spy. You feel his horror as the programme he was the author of spins completely out of his control. Brian Cox is also great as Conklin's boss, channeling his considerable power into the two handers between them.

I do feel that most of the blame for this film's failings, as I said earlier, are down to the director, rather than the cast. I fully appreciate and Damon has gone on the record to say that without Doug Liman, this film and the franchise would not exist. But there are as many shortcomings as there are great moments. And it is strange, as some of his other films, particularly Edge of Tomorrow & American Made, are fantastic films. You sort of wonder how the same man made those two films when you compare it to this one.

There are definitely some good moments, but for me, this is and always will be the weakest of the franchise. Watch this and then immediately put on/rent Bourne Supremacy. That is a masterpiece.

What happened to the book's story line? - The Bourne Identity review by CP Customer

The big advantage is that you can read the book and see the film without having to decide which is better.