The wildest, craziest plot ever imagined. It is set in Madrid and claims to be a true story told by carnival people! Lon Chaney plays a serial killer known to the police only for the strange double thumbs on his left hand. So he straps his arms behind his back and joins a travelling circus as a knife act, throwing daggers at a very young Joan Crawford with his feet. Who he loves...
Because of previous abuse, the girl can't stand to be touched. So she is neurotically repulsed by the attentions of the circus strongman (Norman Kerry). As the police close in, to hide his incriminating thumbs and to indulge her fetishistic attraction to him, Chaney has both his arms removed by a surgeon he is blackmailing!
Unfortunately, when he returns to the circus, the showgirl has got over her fear of being touched and married the muscleman. The now insanely jealous knife thrower devises a hideous revenge! Phew. This is pretty uninhibited stuff. The story was created by Tod Browning who left home as a child to join a circus. Chaney's upbringing was equally unconventional.
Many silent horrors have the illusory mania of a febrile dream. And that is the great attraction here. And it's a lot of fun watching Chaney acting (brilliantly) with his feet. Browning and Chaney did astonishing work elsewhere, but there was an alchemy when they worked together. It feels like absolutely anything is possible.