Based in the trailer and the description I anticipated enjoying this. The story is probably fine, a bit bitty as I got rather annoyed with Charlize's refusal to tell anybody from the beginning what really happened on the fateful night and knowing it was not perpetrated by the person convicted.
Nicolas Hoult with a decent American accent does well with his Kill Club reasoning and begins to sway Libby Day's reluctance. Why the police failed to find out anything about all these other people's relationships to each other I find indefensible. I THINK it all got resolved but from about 1/3 of the way into the film I was shouting at all the scenes filmed in the dark "for heavens sake turn the *** lights on - I can't see what's going on !!"
Couldn't make out locations, characters or actions and that just lost me to the rest and gave up watching.
I enjoyed the book and was hoping it would make a successful jump to the screen like Gillian Flynn's Gone Girl. Unfortunately, it is a by the numbers thriller than goes from one clue to another without any tension or red herrings to keep you on your toes. Charlize Theron just manages to look slightly annoyed throughout, probably more suited to a TV series than a film.
Excellent adaptation of the book. You just have to know who murdered them all; and this will keep you guessing to the very end. The flashbacks meld seamlessly with the present-day story. Theron carries the weight of the proceeding on her shoulders, creating a multi-layered memorable character. Sharp direction, choosing tough realism rather than fragile gloss. If you like a convoluted mystery, set against a stark backdrop, you'll like this.