Inconsistent with an idiotic ending
- Inglourious Basterds review by CP Customer
'Inglorious Basterds' is a deceptive film, though the film is promoted as a story about a small unit of Jewish-American soldiers who use guerrilla tactics to ambush Nazi platoons and brutally massacre them leaving one sole survivor to tell the tale, the film is actually two separate stories which come together at the end. The 'Basterds' storyline sadly only makes up roughly a third of the film, the other two thirds revolve around the character of 'Shosanna' a young Jewish woman who escapes the mass execution of her family by an SS officer named Colonel Landa. While the storyline is pretty good the film as a whole is spoiled by Tarantino's over direction and obsession for adding quirks for the sake of being quirky, a prime example are the opening titles which are in four completely different fonts. The dialogue is in three different languages, 'The Basterds' scenes of the film are in English while the dialogue in 'Shosannas' scenes are in French and German with English subtitles, and while I don't mind subtitles, the foreign language dialogue, (though relevant in the opening scene), seemed pointless in such a mainstream film and seemed more about Tarantino showing off about directing scenes in French and German. Another problem is the inconsistent cast, the foreign language cast of French actress Mélanie Laurent, German actress Diane Kruger, German Actor Daniel Brühl and Austrian Christoph Waltz were all nothing short of superb, with Waltz's portrayal of Hans Landa the highlight of the film. The English speaking cast on the other hand were a real let down especially the usually fine Brad Pitt as the U.S officer Lieutenant Aldo Raine who spends most scenes looking dumb and pulling faces. But what completely spoiled the film for me were the final scenes. World war two was a historical event; there any many WWII fictional films which are based within the limitations of historical events, but without spoiling the film Tarantino creates a fictitious ending which completely rewrites history. And while most rational people will see 'Inglorious Basterds' as a work of fiction there already are plenty of posts on forums and community blogs from many people asking if it was a true story and is that how the war ended? Tarantino doesn't do himself any favours to rectify the film is a work of fantasy by stating in the end credits 'Based on actual events'. Overall, though touted by many as a return to form for Tarantino the film is a fairly decent effort, maybe on a par with 'Jackie Brown', but certainly not as bad as 'Deathproof'. I would have given it three stars but it gets two for the idiotic ending.
5 out of 9 members found this review helpful.
Inglorious Cobblers
- Inglourious Basterds review by CP Customer
Very, very disappointing. End of. I did write quite a long review for this film but I scrapped it on the grounds that enough time has been wasted with this effort as it is. If you're really stuck then watch it. Otherwise get Axis of War out instead
3 out of 7 members found this review helpful.
I was only obeying orders!
- Inglourious Basterds review by CP Customer
In my view typical Tarantino but not in the class of Pulp Fiction or Rservoir Dogs. Whilst the ending rewrites history I guess I was pleased and maybe this is how the war should have ended.
Brad Pitt give a good performance as Lieutenant Aldo Raine although his accent made me smile throughout. For me though the star is Christopher Walz and his 'baddy' character Colonel Hans Landa. I enjoyed it and if you don't take it too seriously you will too.
3 out of 3 members found this review helpful.
Absolute Rubbish
- Inglourious Basterds review by CP Customer
World War 2 was a matter of life and death to many people and not a bloody pantomime!
This film is an insult not only to the allied forces in Europe but also to many of the Germans.
Unfortunately, I would not be surprised should many credulous viewers actually believe this to be part of our history.
2 out of 4 members found this review helpful.
Incongruous bilge
- Inglourious Basterds review by CP Customer
I can see the atraction for Brad to play his role but not Samuel L Jackson. This is the usual "Us Americans saved the world in WWII" crap, until the last few minutes (if you can be bothered to sit through it that long) and then it all goes wrong for them except they have a get out clause at the end where good old Uncle Sam makes @em pay in the end.
Its Resevoir Dogs and Kill Bill meet the Nazis and not in a good way.
Rather lacking from Tarantino. He is one of my favourite directors but this is poor.
2 out of 3 members found this review helpful.
Worst movie of the last 5 years
- Inglourious Basterds review by PV
This is a dire movie, even by QT's plummeting standards. Silly, badly written (repetitive dialogue; dialogue that is clearly Tarantino's voice spoken by several characters, so not differentiation). Ridiculous rewriting of history (why?) for no purpose. Silly pantomime-ish hiss-boo portrayal of Nazis. Utterly absurd and deeply unenjoyable.
How this ever made money and got nominated for awards is beyond me. It is trash. No stars.
1 out of 3 members found this review helpful.
good war film
- Inglourious Basterds review by CP Customer
a good action war film which starts of wiv jews getting hunted and ends wiv a single jew getting her own bak on the nasty nazis would reccommed watching to any body
1 out of 10 members found this review helpful.
Great Start Little Else
- Inglourious Basterds review by CP Customer
Tarantino’s decline continues with Inglorious Basterds, a film that is in dire need of trimming, a decent script and a steady hand. What we have here veers between comedy, drama and a thriller, with the latter representing the strongest aspect of the movie. It’s greatest moment is the opening period where we are first introduced to Colonel Hans Landa, marvellously portrayed by Christoph Waltz who is the real star of Inglorious Basterds. After this highpoint the film descends into farce and mockery, never managing to scale such heights again. Tarantino continues to annoy and frustrate as while this is an improvement on Death Proof, his childish script antics have ruined what should have been a knockout war movie.
1 out of 4 members found this review helpful.
A subversive & great film by Tarantino, with great performances despite some script flaws
- Inglourious Basterds review by TB
Before Inglorious Basterds (IG) was released, Tarantino had frequently alluded to & talked about the WW2 action film he was going to make. After the financial failure of Death Proof, Tarantino dug out the half-finished script of IG & finished it. The result is a brilliant, although sometimes too talky film which nevertheless still to me is his best film of the most recent ones he has done.
The story, as with most of Tarantino's films, is split into several narratives. It imagines an alternate setting of WW2 & involves a French orphan, a group of Jewish American soldiers (the Basterds of the title) & finally the British undercover mission to kill Hitler. Along the way, there are many of the staples of Tarantino which are brilliant, such as Mexican standoffs, meaty dialogue & strong characters.
The thing which I did like most of all about this film & is in no way a spoiler is the rug-pull element of it: as much as it is marketed as an action film & there are some combat-scenes, this movie is much more interested in character & story. The titular Basterds themselves barely appear for a good chunk of the film & you hear much of their exploits through the anecdotes of the traumatised Nazi's who managed to survive encountering them.
The opening scene in particular is an absolute powerhouse of tension building, proving again just how much of a master of his craft Tarantino is with script & setting. We are also introduced to Hans Landa, an incredible multi-lingual character played to perfection by Christoph Waltz. Nicknamed the Jew Hunter, he is remorseless in his pursuit of the terrified people trying to escape the Nazi machine slaughtering them without mercy. Despite his absolutely dispicible motives, Landa is a wonderful character, constantly subverting expectations. And most of all, his refusal to be pigeonholed by anyone or any ideology.
Opposite him, Brad Pitt is also great as Aldo Raine, the Tennessee soldier with an accent as thick as Molasses sugar & on a mission to kill as many Nazis as possible with his platoon. His interactions, particularly with Landa, are a highlight: these two men who couldn't be more different in their beliefs seeing & respecting their shared drive. Raine looks at what is going on around him with horror & disgust, further emboldening him to complete his mission.
And finally, Melanie Laurant as Shoshanna is a worthy & compelling character, the orphan who is determined to track down & kill as many of the people responsible for killing her family as she can. Her interactions with Landa are also, once she recognises him, filled with tension.
Unfortunately, amongst all this good stuff, there is also a lot of bloat, particularly in a scene set in a coffee shop. Tarantino cuts away from the story to obsessively watch a group of Germans eating cake & talking at great length, slamming the brakes onto the narrative. Although the film does manage to pull itself back, it was an unnecessary & quite frustrating interruption, making the film longer than it needed to be.
Then we get to the ending & in true Tarantino style, everything goes crazy, but enjoyably so. It is a bonkers but also deliriously silly finale, setting just the right tone & giving us the payoff we wanted.
As for performances, they are all great, including the cameo's from people such as Mike Myers. Everything else, from the uniforms down to the locations is also excellent.
A riot of a film and one which, despite some flaws, I loved & feel probably won't be bettered with whatever QT makes next.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.
Glourious war drama
- Inglourious Basterds review by CP Customer
Excellent war drama starring Brad Pitt. He was sometimes not very convincing in this film but this is worth a watch. Very explicit and the subtitles move at a very fast pace.
0 out of 3 members found this review helpful.