It's quite surprising to remember that this wasn't that big a success when it was released considering it is now a perennial Christmas favourite and often thought of as the ultimate romantic comedy. The intertwining stories of loves lost and found that are told on the five weeks run up to Christmas are a mixed bag and there are some misfires in there. These can be forgiven because they are well concealed by the sheer fun and magic of the film as a whole. Outstanding are Alan Rickman and Emma Thompson as the married couple shattered when he has a brief affair with his secretary. Thompson's performance here is magnificent and on every viewing you can't help feel her pain and sadness. Hugh Grant as the UK Prime Minister is great casting although the choice of TV soap actress Martine McCutcheon as his ideal girl is one of the film's odd decisions and their story arc doesn't fully work. But the dance scene in 10 Downing Street has fallen into the famous scene category. Liam Neeson as a bereaved husband helping his young stepson deal with unrequited love is a great story as is Andrew Lincoln's love for his best friend's wife. The comedy mostly works especially Bill Nighy as the has-been rock star Billy Mack who's Christmas pop song is used to link the stories. Nighy is always great and here is no exception. The film may have become too familiar to too many but on a cold winter evening in front of the fire it never fails to bring a smile and the odd tear to your eye.
As a middle-aged man I was apprehensive about this film but went with the views of a critic in a national newspaper that it should be watched - and I was very pleasantly surprised. A whole host of household names with multi-threaded intertwined storylines (that you have to keep an eye out for *during* the film and not via Wikipedia, as I did), all with feel-good intentions and amusing (but not funny/hilarious), low-key scenes, leading to the inevitable pairing off at the conclusion of the film, cleverly shot at a Christmas concert and Heathrow to bring the whole shebang together, tying the threads into a single entity of love. A typical British feel-good film with effortless acting, self-deprecating humour and clever storyline. Yes to watching it if you are in any doubt