His failure to get you to suspend disbelief is unbelievable considering the excellent raw materiel.
when you look over Mamet's oeuvre, you realise his successes have always been when a real movie director has realised his writing.
this film has a great premise and an excellent plot. it should make an outstanding film in the right hands. unfortunately, Mamet who is a good play write cant direct. he takes some excellent actors and pretty well all the right ingredients for success and somehow contrives to waste them all on a tedious and implausible trudge through some lovely scenery without ever letting the viewer get out of the awareness of the fact that this is a film about a con trick of some sort.
finally when you see exactly what, you do get a sense of relief rather than a sense of excitement and revelation.
such a pity.
I hate remakes but this could do with one.