Rent Fish Tank (2009)

Depressing - Fish Tank review by CM

Perhaps too true to life for some people. There was nothing good about this film. The current recession is making life hard for most people due to the uncertaintity about the future, so we need a bit of escapism which you do not get from this film.

Awful, over-rated, boring British film - Fish Tank review by PV

There is nothing good about this film. It's the kind of sub-Ken Loach and sub-Mike Leigh poverty porn realism much loved by critics - but really, it is patronising, dishonest, self-indulgent pap.

I come from the same homw town as the dirctor and I can tell you that is is mostly middle-class suburbia too! So the portrayal of it as some kind of awful sink estate in dishonest.

What we need are good stories well told - that is what we need in the British film industry; not this awful tedious pity party - this film is typical of all that is wrong with British film-making.

NO STARS.

A film to admire rather than like - Fish Tank review by RP

This film won the 2010 BAFTA for Outstanding British Film – and rightly so. It's not a pretty story – but it will grab you and not let you go until it reaches its inevitable conclusion. 15 year old Mia (an astonishing role by Katie Jarvis) lives with her single, slutty, mother and younger sister in a high rise block of council flats in Rainham, Essex, within sight of the Dartford Crossing QE II bridge. [Aside: the location is the Mardyke Estate, also seen in 'Made In Dagenham' and now being redeveloped].

Mia's mother moves her boyfriend Connor in. Mia finds Connor not only useful as a source of cash and a video camera to record her dancing - which he encourages - but also finds him attractive. There is a certain inevitability as we watch the film that things will almost certainly go wrong - and of course they do. Mia's world slowly unravels as she has sex with Connor, find out that he is (of course) married, that (of course) he has a child and that her dreams of becoming a dancer are (of course) hopelessly unrealistic.

Yes, it's a downbeat film – but it has a realism and feels so true to a certain gritty slice of life and the personalities and the f-ing and blinding that goes with it that it is very watchable through to its ending which is happier than you might expect. 5/5 stars. Highly recommended – but it's a film to admire rather than like.

Rambling diary - Fish Tank review by JD

A troubled, miserable 15 year old lives a joyless life with no talent and no hope. The plot is haphazard picking out episodes of despair apparently at random as she slides into the moral and emotional abyss. This unstructured, shakey hand held camera format gives it a greater air of impoverishment. At the end a pall of gloom will envelope you for days. It is not really what I want from a film. Watch if you need bringing down.

A game of two halves - Fish Tank review by Promessi

Initially we get a rivetting picture of a lowlife household with mum and two daughters (15 and about 8 yo) Fassbender turns up as Mum's fancy man and sets about redeeming all three with his humanity and charisma. But both plot and themes become less and less plausible the further we go. The three witches are transmogrified into three angels and it is all too cosy nice-nice.My favourite absurdity is the Usain Bolt turn of speed by a tiny tot as part of the climax : if you have chortles prepare to guffaw them.

An outstanding British film - Fish Tank review by PT

Katy Jarvis plays Mia, a rebellious, troubled and tough teenager, with dance aspirations. Underneath this hard exterior though are glimpses of a caring girl, who given a different environment and a mothers full love and attention, one could see Mia being a different person altogether.

Kierston Wareing is great as Mia's mother, more interested in partying and men than giving her daughters a proper upbringing. Rebecca Griffiths is great too, as Mia's younger sister Tyler, a future Mia in the making.

Last, but not least of the main protagonists is Michael Fassbender as Connor, Joanne's latest love interest. A man who appears to be kind and interested in the kids as well as just the mother, Fassbender gives a strong performance.

It is Katy Jarvis though who gives the outstanding performance here, unbelievably in her acting debut. Apparently she was spotted on a railway station by a talent scout working for the director. A fact that is more unbelievable is that before Fish Tank she had no acting credentials.

This is the first feature I have seen by this director and am more than very impressed with this phenomenal film. Will definitely be checking out more of Andrea Arnold's work.

Really awful. - Fish Tank review by CP Customer

Dreadful, a lot of swearing, OK in some instances, but it has to have something else going for it, not just dancing and

jumping up and down.