HANNAH HAUXWELL MEETS BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN!
- God's Own Country review by WH
Quite possibly the BEST British film with a gay theme. Its up there alongside Merchant & Ivory's ' Maurice' and Dirk Borardes 1961 groundbreaking 'Victim'. Owing much to Brokeback Mountain- it is a far more realistic representation of a gay man's life- growing up in a close-knit family farm on the North York Morors in the UK. The direction is excellent- as is the cinematography and acting. Really my only criticism would be over the 'deleted scenes'. Personally I don't think any of them need to have been deleted! Highly recommended.
4 out of 4 members found this review helpful.
Brokeback Mountain meets Ilkley Moor bah tat
- God's Own Country review by Pete W
A rather familiar storyline very much based on Brokeback Mountain and some of the scenes and motifs are a direct lift - strip down washes in a bucket, skinny dipping, left behind clothing - but I don't think this detracts from the story. Unlikely to do much to encourage people to take up farming in Yorkshire amongst the racists in the pub, it is a touching story of how an emotionally repressed young farmer gradually realises that he needs help and support from an immigrant worker with whom he has developed a relationship more meaningful than the quick shags in the back of his trailer or in pub toilets. Good performances from the two leads but strong support too from Gemma Jones as a grandmother who knows more than she lets on and Ian Hart as father incapacitated by a stroke.
4 out of 5 members found this review helpful.
Exceptional cinematography
- God's Own Country review by TB
To call this film a Yorkshire version of Brokeback Mountain, serves as a massive discredit to what is an excellent film. Brokeback Mountain was a good film but was pretentious and over dramatised in places as per most Hollywood films. Whereas this film was believable, raw and emotional. It also had exceptional cinematography, which could have easily of seen the film play out without any words needed at all.
The acting was solid by all four of the main characters to deliver two key relationships in the film with great quality. The relationship between the father and son was tense and heartless but became so beautifully tender in the end. While the homosexual relationship between the son and the new farmhand had scenes that were poetic and powerful as two different characters battled with each other along their journey, seeing the troubled son going from an angry, lost and confused young man to someone who wanted to become a man and someone who had been deeply touched by the love and affection he’d never seemingly been shown.
An excellent film!
2 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
Brokeback Mountain in Yorkshire
- God's Own Country review by JR
This is basically a Brokeback Mountain set in Yorkshire. But unlike Brokeback, which looked like and advertisement for Ralph Lauren clothes, this film shows the hardship and isolation of fell farmers. But it's preoccupation with mud, muck and all types of human body fluids was hard to stomach.
2 out of 9 members found this review helpful.
An insult to Yorkshire
- God's Own Country review by SKC
A film so shite it couldn't throw up one Yorkshire actor. Meaning, not a single Yorkshire man has to own up to this drivel.
An utter abortion and should deleted from all sources. A wanton yet failed attempt at Yorkshires's version of Wuthering mountain.
1 out of 6 members found this review helpful.
Off to a Bad start
- God's Own Country review by CH
Not prepared (my fault) for the opening of this story, which I put on in my living room to entertain visiting relatives. Taken aback by the graphic scene of seduction (?) or rape(?), due to the howls of disgust/dismay during the first few seconds, I pulled the plug and suggested Scrabble instead. Posted it back in the hope of getting Christopher Robin next time!
Now have read the reviews, so shall re-order when I know I'll be the sole viewer!
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Loved it!
- God's Own Country review by JM
Absolutely loved this film- thought it dealt with the subject matter with sensitivity and although gritty at times was brilliant on a number of levels.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Exceptional..
- God's Own Country review by CB
This film is not ‘shite’. In any way.
A story of a tough rural upbringing and the strains of relationships therein.
The way the director develops the relationship between Johnny and his love, and his dad, is masterful.
And...there is the ending, which to avoid spoilers, is untypical of gay themed movies.
Terrific film.
1 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
Art, agriculture and amour
- God's Own Country review by mc
The film appealed to me because I am gay, I was a farmer (although that farm could never support the family and the foreigner) and I love such beautifully filmed landscape
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.
British Love Story
- God's Own Country review by GI
Almost, but not quite, a British Brokeback Mountain and a very assured first film for director Francis Lee. Set on a Yorkshire farm portrayed as a bleak, somewhat inhospitable place highlighting that living in the country can be a harsh and lonely life and is not always the idyllic one it's thought to be. Josh O'Connor plays Jack, a disheartened young man who has had to take over the running of the family's farm after his father (Ian Hart) has had a stroke. With only his grandmother (Gemma Jones) and father, seemingly always unimpressed by Jack's efforts, as company Jack resorts to drink and sullenness. All of his former school mates have gone off to University and Jack's only comradeship comes from chance encounters in toilets with local gay men. But when the family hire Gheorghe (Alec Secareanu), a Romanian worker, Jack's life begins to find a meaning as they begin a passionate relationship. Lee's use of lighting from a harsh, cold look to warmer tones as Gheorghe begins to affect Jack is clever and signposts the affect of love. Gheorghe brings ideas to the farm and his presence affects all the relationships. There's an especially touching moment between Jack and his father. Interestingly the only bias Gheorghe experiences doesn't come from homophobia by the typical locals but from being an immigrant worker highlighting the Brexit issues that were focused on immigration especially in the north of England. A tender film, unsentimental with strong central performances.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.