Phew what a scorcher
- In the Cut review by JD
It has to be stated at the outset that this is a highly sexual film. But do not think that it is cheap, it is really gripping. The characters are immensely complex and very interesting. The plot (it is outwardly a detective film) is good. The drama spot on. Scoring such a violent and pornographic film with a 5 star I did for the dramatic impact and intensity of emotion not for any smutty motive. Definitely an 18 rated. Not for winding down to.
2 out of 3 members found this review helpful.
Doesn't Make The Cut
- In the Cut review by CP Customer
Shot moodily. Lit dimly. Acted badly.
It's almost a case of someone having a vague idea of what makes a thriller work but not having ever seen one before.
Oddly unengaging, considering the two leads, and frankly nonsensical in execution.
At no point did I beleive in her character or her attraction to the cop, particularily as her suspicions mount. The conclusion is utterly ridiculous, though I'm sure has symbolic meaning. Meta-themed thrillers are fine just so long as you care about the hero and can find humanity in their plight beyond the hidden meanings of the plot.
Rubbish.
2 out of 5 members found this review helpful.
Good thriller
- In the Cut review by CP Customer
Slightly surprising role for Meg Ryan. I guess she wanted to break the mould of being type cast as romantic heroine. There are some moments where her part's behavior is not totally believable, but the plot kept me guessing right up to the end. I thought the gratuitously explicit sex was unnecessary to the plot, but I'm not complaining.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Great film
- In the Cut review by HC
Very dark and quite explicit but an excellent storyline, plenty of twists and good performances from the leads. Took me by surprise by I throughly enjoyed it.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.
Disappointing
- In the Cut review by CP Customer
I did not enjoy the film at all! Found it pretty boring, I have liked Meg Ryan in other films I have seen and I had been looking forward to watching her in this one!
0 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Tasteless
- In the Cut review by SC
This film was pornographic and focused largely on the main female character's sexual exploits or lack of,
I switched off after 30 minutes I am shocked that an actress of Meg Ryan's calibre agreed to do this film
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.
Underrated Erotic Thriller
- In the Cut review by GI
An erotically charged murder mystery with Meg Ryan in a risqué performance that goes against her normal screen persona. She is very good too as the sexually repressed teacher who starts an affair with the detective (Mark Ruffalo) who is investigating the series of murders of young women in the area. As their passionate relationship develops a casual lie soon leads her to suspect her now lover maybe the killer. There's a dark edge to this thriller and the narrative follows a path that one minute you think you know the killer and the next you change your mind. There are clues but really that is a superficial aspect to this underrated film. The really interesting aspect is the emotional journey that Ryan's character has to follow and how repressed memories of her parents, her protectiveness towards her sister (Jennifer Jason Leigh) and her past relationship with the weird hospital worker (Kevin Bacon) all intertwine with her reasons for the affair she risks with the detective even as she begins to think he maybe the murderer. It's a superb script, brilliantly directed by Jane Campion and a film that deserves rediscovery.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.