Standard british drama
- Military Wives review by TH
Military wives is one of those british films that entertains with a likeable cast of actors and some laughs mix with sadder moments. This feels like the sort of film you would happily watch in a sunday afternoon and enjoy.
Sharon Horgan is great as always and the supporting cast are good too.
It's a good story and worth a watch but not sure it would warrant repeat viewing.
4 out of 4 members found this review helpful.
Not my cup of tea but the film has merit
- Military Wives review by JB
Perhaps 3 stars is a bit mean but didnt think it worthy of 4 .Well acted ,cast are believable but lacks a spark.I won't share the plot line as I think you probably know it .Suffice to say the speed that the "choir" went from 1st practice to a perfect song at the Albert Hall was very quick .To the films credit it's meant wives in the military starting choirs all over the world so fair play to it.Would have given it 3/& a half if I could. JB
2 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
Heart wrenching but beautiful
- Military Wives review by giantrolo
Loved this film! It was a proper tear jerker - I spent about 25% of the film quietly sobbing! - but it was so lovely that it was worth the tears. It shines a spotlight on a really important part of society that I never really thought about (or considered existed) - the wives or partners of those brave soldiers who go out and fight for their country. Excellent performances, lovely vocals and definitely a highly recommended film!
2 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
Better than i thought
- Military Wives review by HO
This film really moved me. Beautifully acted and filmed, it really captures the life of these wives, without judgement one way or the other. I loved it, i was moved and i feel educated after watching it. So great to see a British film that hasn't been adulterated for the American market.
2 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
Typical, Clichéd Comedy/Drama
- Military Wives review by GI
A by the numbers comedy drama based on a true story that has its heart warming and funny moments but is so predictable in its intentions and story that it soon becomes unrewarding. The trouble is it lacks the gravitas of theme that similar films have dished out in spades, such as Brassed Off (1996), The Full Monty (1997 from the same director Paul Cattaneo) and even Calendar Girls (2003). All of the characters are thinly sketched with only Kristin Scott Thomas' Kate being given anything remotely interesting and even her backstory isn't fully explored. She is the brittle wife of an army officer who having an emotional hole in her life (the aforementioned backstory fits in here) decides she should try and rally the other wives when their husbands (and one wife) are sent off to Afghanistan. This starts a thin theme of class struggle as Kate finds it difficult to bond with the enlisted soldiers partners mostly played out through the character of confident Lisa (Sharon Horgan). When someone has the idea to form a choir Kate thinks its all hymns and sheet music whereas Lisa, and of course everyone else, wants harmonised pop songs. This sets the narrative off, very quickly, to them being quite good at it. Sadly even the song that Lisa writes for them to perform and which becomes an object of tension with her and Kate is rather bland by the time we get to hear it. Loosely based on a BBC documentary it will surprise some that impresario Gareth Malone is entirely absent, not even mentioned in fact, especially as he is the creative genius behind the military wives choirs that sprung up around the country. This is a film that will fill a couple of hours, will make you chuckle at times and many will like that it goes exactly how you assume it will. Once over its forgettable.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.