Good Ole Western
- Open Range review by CP Customer
My husband probably enjoyed this more than I did, but it was a very satisfying evening's viewing - as you would expect from Costner, this wasn't a prettified version of the West - and it was good to be reminded that cowboys actually herded cows in between getting into fights and philandering with bargirls!
2 out of 3 members found this review helpful.
A good western
- Open Range review by CP Customer
Solid Costner film although in need of a little editing, it remains enjoyable. Costner and a few others are freegrazers, minding their own business until a local landowner and those under his influence take offence, with dramatic consequences.
Costner's character remains quite mysterious throughout the film, by then I was quite mystified to his past. A little more detail here would have been welcome.
2 out of 6 members found this review helpful.
An enjoyable and absorbing Western.
- Open Range review by CP Customer
The plot of ‘Open Range’ is fairly lightweight, with free-range cattlemen ‘Boss’ and ‘Charley’ driving their herd across the grass plains of Montana along with their hired hands ‘Mose’ and ‘Button’. After ‘Mose’ is sent into a nearby town to collect supplies, he is involved in an unfair fight and thrown into jail. When ‘Boss’ and ‘Charley’ ride into town looking for their friend they are told by the sheriff and local land baron Denton Baxter that free-rangers are not welcome in their town and to move on, and after their camp is attacked they are forced to make a decision, leave the herd and save themselves or face Baxter, his henchmen and his corrupt sheriff and make a stand. Though the plot is a little generic what sets ‘Open Range’ apart from the average western is a superb cast and incredibly well paced direction from Kevin Costner. Robert Duvall as ‘Boss’ always excels in this type of genre and Kevin Costner is surprisingly good as Duvall’s quieter, more reserved partner whose violent past as a former gunslinger and civil war soldier still haunts him. Costner’s direction and pacing of the film is spot on, opening the film in an idyllic landscape with a gentle tone which gradually turns darker as the story progresses, and the final 30 minutes of the film are genuinely tense and thrilling. If you’re looking for a decent western then this should be on your list, and if you enjoy ‘Open Range’ you should check out the superb ‘Broken Trail’ which is very similar in tone.
2 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
One-dimensional characters and story with made-for-TV feel, but fine if you like Kevin Costner.
- Open Range review by PS
Two-thirds through this film I found myself wandering around the living room tidying up, not paying attention. That is how un-engaging I found it.
A friend recommended 'Open Range' to me, after I was singing the praises of Clint Eastwood's 'Unforgiven'. The friend described Open Range as a similar story to Unforgiven and worth watching. The two stories are superficially similar but Open Range has none of the subtlety, nuance, or intelligence of Unforgiven. The only character with much depth or charm is Robert Duvall playing 'Boss'. Kevin Costner plays Kevin Costner: attempting the moody and mysterious ageing cowboy but failing to pull it off convincingly for me. In case you didn't get the clumsy hints about his troubled past and emotional baggage, he just blurts out his backstory by the campfire one evening, as if it's a therapy session.
Without giving too many spoilers, the baddies are all one-note nasty gits bent on greed and vindictive violence, while the plucky townsfolk are only too happy to fall in behind Costner and Duvall, as they are clearly the righteous goodies.
Saying all that, the final shootout is very well done and might be worth the laboured build-up, if you enjoy Costner's antics.
Summing up, all the way through I was thinking about how much better Unforgiven is in every way. Wish I had watched that again instead of this.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Absorbing Western
- Open Range review by CD
Robert Duvall and Kevin Costner lift this above the ordinary but the plot is not very sophisticated and it feels overlong. The wider array of characters and their warming towards the free grazers’ cause is well done, and the extended gunfight is a powerful bit of filming . The film misses a chance to go deeper into the lead characters and their motivations. There are quite a few night shots so if your TV is as bad as mine in coping with low light then you may struggle with seeing some of the action.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.
Good storyline
- Open Range review by AB
I liked this - the story has been seen before a hundred times in westerns (and other genres) but the pulling together of the sub-plots was enjoyable. Life was tough in those days and corruption probably rife, but there must have been good guys like the main protagonists to help build a huge country from nothing.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.