Oh dear
- Typist Artist Pirate King review by Alphaville
Here we go again. Yet another doggedly-filmed, dialogue-heavy, actorly product of the British film industry. It’s based on a true story and means well, so no wonder it was beloved of the arthouse circuit, which helps proliferate this kind of non-cinematic bore. Among real film lovers it sank without trace. As usual, better suited to the stage or TV.
1 out of 4 members found this review helpful.
Charming eccentric British road move
- Typist Artist Pirate King review by MM
Great music, lovely acting, tantalising art, very funny, not at all American. A moving exploration of mental illness
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Not as good as I was hoping
- Typist Artist Pirate King review by LC
Although the film is OK, the events are mostly made up, so the amount that this reflects on Audrey Amiss herself is unclear. Monica Dolan is great as always, but the road-trip style of the film made it too convenient and unbelievable to take seriously.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Didn't ring true to life
- Typist Artist Pirate King review by CB
I only found out belatedly (after I'd given up on it just over half way through) that this was based on a true story. My problem with it was that it didn't ring true. Having known many people with a range of different mental health conditions, there was very little in this that felt 'true to life'. The performances felt like people acting rather than real believable people.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Good in parts, a character study of mental illness of Audrey Amiss (1933-2013)
- Typist Artist Pirate King review by PV
I mostly enjoyed this film, with reservations. It is better than most BFI/lottery-funded films BUT not on the level of truly great road trip movies like WITHNAIL AND I or THELMA AND LOUISE. Very 2nd division. There have been loads of films recently about people going off on long walks, the mediocre schmaltzy UNLIKELY PILMGRAMAGE OF HAROLD FRY and the D-Day films two of them, one with Michael Caine.The best of all is FIRST AND LAST (1987) with Joss Ackland.
In particular, some male characters the two women meet on their roadtrip are cartoon character baddies - just absurdly so. Real misandry really, from a female writer/director there, I felt. Not necessary. To try and balance that obviously, there is a kind male policeman (ironic, as the real Audrey Amiss was often arrested for civil disturbance by police and locked up in mental hospitals; she even got deported from China for that when on many travels with her mother). Other very unrealistic and posed meetings with various groups - I doubt any of this really happened but Audrey Amiss did exist and was severely mentally ill.
Her archive is in the Wellcome collection - not as art, and scrapbooks of chocolate bar wrappers is what I did as a very small kid, so not art. But that collection has artefacts which link art, life, mental illness, so...
No idea how true to life this is. Audrey Amiss born 1933 died 2013, started scrapbooks late 70s - lived in Clapham near/with her mother, so not short of money really - they travelled the world together, exotic trips.
The performance of Monica Dolan was superb - and that carries this whole film really. I found her companion and former nurse annoying. I thought the mental illness and delusion was handled well. Always tricky to do, that.
So good in parts, annoying at times, great acting in main role, 3 stars. Almost 4. Great music too, oldies and newer songs too, one from Boy George plays over the credits (watch the end to see real art by Audrey and her photo).
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.