Stunning
- The Quiet Girl review by AER
This is just about the best Irish film I've ever seen and one of the most moving portrayals about childhood. 10 out of 10.
6 out of 6 members found this review helpful.
Beautiful
- The Quiet Girl review by sb
FILM & REVIEW Aka The Quiet Girl - beautifully understated film set in the rural countryside in 1981. Catherine Clinch plays Cait a number of siblings on a farm on the poverty line. The Mother is about to give birth to yet another child so Cait is farmed out to a remote cousin Eibhlin (Crowly) and her husband Sean (Benett) who are far more prosperous and live in a large farmhouse. At first Cait is a bit lost among the space and silence but Eibhlin looks after her and makes sure she settles in. Sean however is a remote taciturn man who more or less ignores the newcomer but over the summer the two begin to bond. It’s revealed that the couple had a child of their own but he drowned so Cait becomes a surrogate…and that’s about it… But first class performances especially from Clinch and a refusal to wallow in sentiment lift this way above its kitchen sink origins as does the photography and sound design. - a little gem really - 4/5
5 out of 5 members found this review helpful.
Quietly beautiful
- The Quiet Girl review by PD
This delicate and unsurprisingly quiet debut piece from Colm Bairéad follows Cáit, a shy, sad schoolgirl in an unhappy family, sent away to spend the summer with her mother’s cousin. There, she’s shown a simple, uncomplicated tenderness, gradually forging a family of the kind she’s clearly never experienced before - Carrie Crowley as Eibhlín in particular giving a low-key but totally convincing portrayal of someone transformed by the newcomer, whilst Catherine Clinch as Cáit gives a mature, understated yet powerful performance well beyond her years, her face betraying anxieties she doesn’t yet fully understand at every turn.
The dialogue almost entirely consists in a gentle and lyrical Irish - tellingly, the few English speakers in the film are characters Cáit fears or struggles to trust, such as her belligerent, emotionally inert father - and though the attention is focused on its central figure, the film is full of people unable to express themselves, inner turmoil in different forms. Cáit’s parents are sad and unfulfilled; Cáit herself struggles to make friends; and her foster parents, though much more open and loving, have a grief-filled history they are not fully sharing: it takes acts of mutual care and affection for any lines of communication to open. There's also a vinegary tang of black comedy and cynicism provided by neighbour Úna (a brief but terrific turn from Joan Sheehy) who looks after Cáit one afternoon and brutally tells the girl all about what her foster parents aren’t telling her - we suspect of course that Eibhlín wanted Úna to shoulder the awful burden of revealing this.
The sedate camerawork never leaves Cáit’s vantage point, and the naturalistic cinematography appropriately finds a comfort in stillness, as does the minimalist score. There's a little too much sentiment occasionally, and the filmmaker is perhaps guilty of manipulating our emotions at times, but overall it's a lovely, tender piece giving us a child's perspective on our fallen world. Sometimes, the film ponders, it’s better not to say anything at all. “She says as much as she needs to say,” Cáit’s adoptive father says of her. “May there be many like her.”
4 out of 4 members found this review helpful.
A devastating, beautiful and moving story of childhood in rural Ireland
- The Quiet Girl review by giantrolo
This was such a quietly solemn and poignant film that was at different moments heartbreaking, harrowing and moving. So well cast and beautifully filmed, it really is a treat to watch. Recommended!
3 out of 3 members found this review helpful.
Lovely Film
- The Quiet Girl review by Peter B
Beautifully filmed and acted. Catherine Clinch is brilliantly subtle and authentic as a shy and troubled child of a poor Irish family in County Waterford in the 1980's. Deliverance and a slow awakening to happiness comes when she is sent to her mother's cousin for the summer holidays. Great photography and an authentic feel to the story.
3 out of 3 members found this review helpful.
You must watch this.
- The Quiet Girl review by PL
My wife and I found this the most beautiful, touching and sensitive exploration of love at the centre (or not) of family life in a rural Irish village. We were left with tears in our eyes.
The dialogue is mostly in Irish Gaelic (subtitled - although telling moments revert to English) but don't let that put you off. The acting is superb from all. Highly recommended is an understatement.
3 out of 3 members found this review helpful.
Simple, quiet, moving
- The Quiet Girl review by JR
This is a quiet, simple film which shows great understanding and tenderness for a withdrawn, neglected and unloved child. It shows Irish rural life in its hardship and also beauty, and there is poetry in the cinematography of the natural surroundings. I found the dialogue difficult to hear, particularly Cait's family, so I was very glad of the subtitles for the Irish dialogue.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Be patient
- The Quiet Girl review by AK
Yes, very understated but holds your attention. Great look. Thought it was shot on film, but amazingly it's shot digitally. Don't be put off by the welsh language as the dialogue is minimal. A good emotional impact as a character-driven drama, unlike more genre-inflected films that the BFI and such bodies often fund.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Dire
- The Quiet Girl review by JG
I thought this would be a charming, pastoral atmospherique Irish film. Instead I find a plodding grim tale (about what?). Much mumbling about 'the harvest'. Unbearable. Sorry this isn't a 'proper' review but this is all I can think to say about it. I could not finish it.
0 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
Language as a social construct?
- The Quiet Girl review by DF
This is a remarkable and beautiful film set in a rural part of Ireland probably in the early 80’s. The movie centres around Cáit (Catherine Clinch), a young ‘quiet’ 10 year old. She is part of a large family living on a small dairy farm. Cáit’s parents are struggling and with the imminent arrival of another child, they decide to send Cáit off, for the summer, to stay with distant (but slightly better off) relatives. Her new carers Sean and Eibhlín (Andrew Bennett and Carrie Crowley) take a gentle and kind interest in Cáit and this awakens the emotional trust in people that, up to now, she has never known. At first Sean is gruff, but slowly a relationship grows with Cáit as she helps him around the farm. Although Eibhlín at one time says to Cáit that there are no ‘secrets in this house’, well, of course, there is a secret, and eventually it is revealed to Cáit by a bitter neighbour Uná ( played ‘spot-on’ by Joan Sheehy). Most of the dialogue is in the Irish language and this I found very pertinent to understanding the social and cultural background in which the movie is set. There is a distance drawn when characters speak in English rather than Irish. English dialogue is terse, uneasy and lacking whilst Irish comes across as lyrical and evocative. Dialogue springs to life, for example, in the card game which is full of ‘craic’ and banter. Very often in the movie there is a persistent background of banal radio and quiz games in mid-Atlantic English. At one point Eibhlín pointedly switches the radio off. (The Irish language and its place in Ireland is a recurring issue, to this day) The director Colm Bairead keeps everything understated, slow, lingering, sensitive, ‘quiet’, but he does let go at the very end and, in my view, perfectly.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.