Epic, sprawling western biopic that was a critical and commercial flop and was unfairly compared with Tombstone (1993) although they are two stylistically different films. Viewed today this film is entertaining, filmed and structured in a very Hollywood standard story telling way and to be honest all the better for it. It does slip in some homages which western fans will spot and attempts to play a part in John Ford's 'print the legend' maxim although a bit too casually to give the film any real gravitas. This is a film to sit back and just enjoy for it's cinematic grandeur and surface history. It is when boiled down a good ol' action western that has a good story, plenty of great action scenes and some stock western characters. Kevin Costner plays Earp as a very serious, emotionally damaged avenger with a story that begins with in his teens (with Ian Bohen in the first scenes as a young Earp), it then tells the story of his life from naïve drover to grieving alcoholic to lawman and killer. There's a good support cast including Gene Hackman as his father, Michael Madsen as his older brother Virgil and a slimmed down Dennis Quaid as Doc Holliday. A film well worth a revisit and re-evaluation because there is much to admire here, not least the sheer scale of the story and for it's attempt at a romanticised and retro style of western.
I rented this on the back of Kevin Costner's excellent 'Open Range’, but this is really an inferior film. The acting is cheesy, the story historically inaccurate and at three hours long it's a struggle to get through. If you've not seen the superb 'Open Range' or 'Broken Trail' then rent them and give this a miss.
A boring and predictable film, done with zero originality and panache. Costner can be very hit and miss at times, and in this his portrayal is merely one-dimensional. Compared to great westerns like Open Range and The Outlaw Josie Wales, it just plods along, and you find yourself studying the costumes and predicting the tired dialogue. Like the 'Little House on the Prairie' with guns, the best bits are those magnificent moustaches that everyone wears!