So-so true take of submarine disaster
- Kursk: The Last Mission review by PV
This movie is unusual as it shows Brits as heroes and not villains, the usual trope. Maybe because it's not really a Hollywood movie and is full of German actors and the aged Max von Sydow as a Soviet era Navy boss.
As per usual, when what happened on the sub is unknown and as we all know what happened in the end, there has to be a lot of stuff invented and events to create narrative structure. These are sometimes successful but at other times seem forced.
I suppose an inevitable comparison is to be made with superior drama such as Chernobyl, and this film looks a bit B-movie by comparison.
But it's worth a look. 2.5 stars rounded up.
6 out of 7 members found this review helpful.
average film of a tragic event
- Kursk: The Last Mission review by JD
Worth a watch just for the subject and the fact its a true story.
It has the appearance and feeling its on the cheap and doesnt stand out as anything special. But it gets the key points across well enough to be a story worth watching.
Center piece is the impact on family, and there is the bond between service men, the lack of funding causing poor training and equipment so lacking and poorly maintained its both useless and incredibly dangerous. All wrapped around the Soviet politics that ultimately make this such a tragedy.
Of course, thats bad enough but when the Royal Navy was going out of its way to help with what would be the best divers and rescue equipment in the world it just makes it much worse.
There is much dramatisation going on to keep the story rolling along, but the key points, the disaster, the family, the politics and a genuine offer of help from great sea-fairing enemy are all covered.
And a term ive not heard before has stuck in my head. Sailors help Sailors. For the crew of kursk it was there comrades and for those watching it was the royal navy. All every mariner wanted was to see them safe.
But Politics.
4 out of 4 members found this review helpful.
Good watch
- Kursk: The Last Mission review by CS
Wasn't sure about this movie but got into it quite quickly. Good storyline and acting by all and certainly keeps your interest. But politically damming in my opinion.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.
Good in parts
- Kursk: The Last Mission review by SB
Like some others I would have preferred that this film be done in Russian with subtitles rather than English, although the effect is less discordant than might have been the case. Some of the film is conjecture, which is fair enough when the full facts may never be known. The scene-setting is done fairly well, and also the increase in tension after the accident and the rescue attempts. But 'Das Boot' this is not. It's telling that the most effective scenes by far are those with the families rather than those with the crew on board. Colin Firth plays his usual slightly pompous commander figure, and is perhaps given too much screen time.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.
A Moving Film with Good Performances
- Kursk: The Last Mission review by CD
This film does a good job in bringing out the personal side of the Kursk tragedy and the bond between the men and between their families waiting on the shore. The difficulty that the leaders in the hierarchy had in communicating what was happening and in accepting any help comes across well. The claustrophobic and perilous environment in the sub is well shot and the main actors are strong. The heroism of the Russian crew comes through strongly, and the film avoids a simplistic judgement on the tragedy and the attempts at rescue.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.
Life is Cheap
- Kursk: The Last Mission review by CP Customer
A interesting film covering what is a documented disaster in the Barents Sea off the USSR Oscar class submarine KURSK sank during the first major USSR naval exercise in ten years, on the 12th August 2000. After failed attempts to rescue the crew they Russian Navy had to turn too late to the Royal Navy to assist them but after all the prevarication and false information being fed to the families of the crew. A thought provoking film and could it happen again?
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.
Tragic true story
- Kursk: The Last Mission review by AC
I though this was told very well in a un-glossy way, perhaps because it wasn't a Hollywood re-telling. This was obviously a tragic event and the film fills that out with not just focusing on the event itself but, adding a bit off background to the characters, the crewmen of the sub. It was a good cast, with a couple German actors who I recognized, although I didn't know their names. Altogether good.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.
A horrible & claustrophobic film which shows the indifference of the Russian leadership
- Kursk: The Last Mission review by TB
Many people will have either forgotten or had never heard of the Kursk submarine tragedy which gripped the world back in 2000. During a naval exercise, a missile on the Kursk submarine exploded, killing a huge number of men inside the submarine and leaving many others stranded and waiting for rescue with the air running out.
And on the surface, the Russian government stonewalled, blocked help and refused to do anything. This is one of those films where the less you know, the more you get out of it, although there is a horrific thread of doom running through the whole movie.
The cast are good, although the story itself at times was a bit poorly told. The film had a habit of building up tension wonderfully, then changing scene and losing that momentum. There was also the sense that the filmmakers had really cut out a lot of interesting events in order to make the film the length it was. This story would make an incredible series, like in the vein of Chernobyl.
A good effort, but in many ways a missed opportunity.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.