Rent Mary Poppins Returns (2018)

Practically imperfect in every way - Mary Poppins Returns review by Pete W

OK, this is a very clever reworking of the original Mary Poppins story but it's nowhere near as entertaining. The parallels with the first film are very close - sweeps become lamplighters, there's a cartoon element accessed via a porcelain bowl rather than a street painting, Uncle Albert has turned into Meryl Streep - and there are some nice homages to the original characters and songs. But the songs really let it down - nothing of the calibre of the songs in the original. Dick van Dyke's appearance is a highlight as he's the only cast member who conveys any of the feel good factor of the first film although he's obviously been passing on his linguistic Cockney skills to Lin-Manuel Miranda.

Surprisingly great and faithful as a sequel to the greatest childrens movie - Mary Poppins Returns review by Tej

The first film is in my all time favourite holiday film. It is a true classic that justifies its status. I never tire watching it simply because its such a magical film filled with the beautiful songs, and a practically perfect cast (yes Dick Van Dyke included! His cockney accent is way over criticised and although no one on earth sounds anything like that, it's charming and I am a born 47 year old Londoner!) and of course Julie Andrews voice and demeanour is mesmerising and unmatched.

So this sequel was a must see for me but I was realistic about my expectations for it. I don't expect it to be anywhere as good as the original but I hoped it would be at least an enjoyable film in its own right.

So, after watching the sequel, I was completely floored. I was on cloud Poppins. It's a huge shock to find that this movie captures the same feeling and quality as the original in almost every way. The songs are stunningly delightful, each one brilliantly performed with the most sumptuous lyrics but absolutely fitting for this surreal world of Mary Poppins. It's as if Robert Sherman was back from the place that "lost things go" to scribe all the songs with his brother. Each song holds its own to match the first film's songs yet one rehash of any of the original songs either.

The characters are as charming as the original in their own way and Mary Poppins herself was ALMOST practically perfect in every way. The versatile immensely talented Emily Blunt is not quite the match for the purity of Julie's voice and she does overdo the shoulder swinging a tad whereas Julie was far more natural in her demeanour...surprising giving Emily's elite standard of acting but she was terrific in her own way with a slightly edgier and aggressive but still playful portrayal. The rest of the cast is lovely with two DIsney legends popping in with a wonderfully substantial contribution of their own and such a joy to see them on the screen in what almost feels like a complete circle of life for those two legends. Streep, a relatively younger legend once again nearly steals the show too. Ben Wishaw is especially excellent as the grown up Bank's son with grief and troubles of his own. The children are lovely too.

The story and atmosphere is somewhat a reflection of the first film but it's not a complete rehash. It's simply a natural follow up and this is a sequel where we don't want drastic changes, we want familiarity and it delivers just that, beautifully,

This is as true a Mary Poppins sequel expansion that you could ever want, maintaining the magical feeling of the original. Quite outstanding.

I still advise you not to expect the quality of the original if you are a fan of the original but to just enjoy everything this love letter has to deliver.

Standout ballad: "Lost Things Go". Standout wacky song: "Turning Turtle"

4.5/10

Fantastic sequel - Mary Poppins Returns review by CP Customer

A perfect sequel to the original. Great songs, knowing reference to the original and spot the stars. Great for Adults and kids.

Even Dick Van Dyke is there. - Mary Poppins Returns review by NC

Worth seeing just for 93 year old Dick Van Dyke in amazing form, plus Angela Lansbury as well!

To be fair I found it boring, but wife liked it. Not sure if a bit slow for kids, and do they like so much music? Not tried it out on any yet.

Is well done though. Blunt does well singing. Replacement for Van Dyke is very competent, but no match for the megga dynamics that was Dick.

The nice normal family live in Paddington type family house in London....circa 5Mill in todays money!

Annoyingly well worth flying a kite for. - Mary Poppins Returns review by RP

When they first said they had made a sequel of one of the best loved children's films of all time. One had to ask why? Who could possibly play Mary Poppins once Julie Andrews is so comfortably singing in your brain. I do love Emily Blunt though and so despite the weird accent She uses I did watch it, with much trepidation. Annoyingly it works and works well. We could do without Meryl Streep character that adds nothing but a reminder of the original better song. We could do without some of the constant reprises of the songs. However that is being a bit harsh for the sake of it. The song by Dad to his late wife is a tearjerker and much of the story rides along happily with a'will they or wont they' solve the big problem given to them. As much as it annoys me to say. I was taking into the film and I guess my fears made me underestimate it. I never give five stars to any film other than the ones I intend to add to my collection. To my surprise I loved it.

Good, but.... - Mary Poppins Returns review by IT

Having watched the original more times than I care to think about, both with my children and all the grandchildren, I was really looking forward to this.

However, I don't think this holds a candle to the original in any way. The songs aren't as memorable, and the storyline isn't up to much.

that said, I enjoyed watching the film, but just kept comparing it to the original Julie Andrews one all the time.

A great family watch. - Mary Poppins Returns review by JG

I loved the original Mary Poppins so was I unsure what to expect with this. This turned out to be a perfect family watch, my son enjoyed it equally as much as myself and my husband. They captured the original with enough updates to make it seem like it had moved on in time.