A Moving Piece
- Stillwater review by SG
This is a good film. I saw it on New Year’s Eve and it touched me.
Loosely based on the Meredith Kercher crime from 10 years ago, this is a deeply enthralling drama. Matt Damon’s character works on an oil rig; he chooses to go to Marseille to try and rescue his daughter from being imprisoned for a murder she says she did not commit. He plays his part extremely well. He doesn’t say much because that is his character, but what he doesn’t say is amplified by his body language and look and actions. He rarely expresses himself emotionally but you know full well deep down he loves his daughter to pieces and will go to the ends of the Earth to help her.
Some of this film is a fish out of water scenario ie he's in the middle of a French city & cannot speak the language and doesn’t understand the culture. It’s a good plot with an intriguing final 3rd to keep you glued to the screen. It’s one of Matt Damon‘s best for many years because he internalises all his emotions. The final scene is a masterpiece in expression… without speaking very much at all.
8/10
6 out of 6 members found this review helpful.
Involving drama
- Stillwater review by Alphaville
Low-key but involving drama about an ordinary mid-West Joe (Matt Damon) travelling to Marseille to prove his imprisoned daughter innocent of murder. Grounded in character and place, there’s no action and no set-pieces, but it’s is so well-plotted and efficiently directed that it keeps you invested from start to finish.
In fact the murder plot is less interesting than Matt’s growing relationship with the mother and young daughter with whom he stays in Marseille. This is beautifully handled.
If anything detracts, it’s the plot’s insistence on going its own idiosyncratic way, whether the audience cares or not. This is brave, but whether it’s successful or foolhardy, only you can judge.
Note to reviewers: please don’t give endings away.
6 out of 6 members found this review helpful.
Good Matt Damon really can act
- Stillwater review by CM
Matt Damon is totally convincable as an oil rigger, not so keen on the story line, strange to see him in a French film, he has a quiet demeanor subtle but powerful performance. The ending was strange, it would have been nice for him to end with the woman and child
4 out of 7 members found this review helpful.
Interesting Drama
- Stillwater review by GI
This drama has Matt Damon playing against type as a father trying to reconnect with his daughter whilst trying to help her prove her innocent of murder. There is a vigilante..ish story here but don't expect Damon to Jason Bourne his way through this story. He plays Bill, an American blue collar worker with past demons, who's daughter Allison (Abigail Breslin) is serving a prison sentence in Marseilles for killing her lover. He visits her whenever he can afford to and on his latest trip she wants her lawyer to get her case reopened on a snippet of information about a boy who she claims is really the guilty one. But much to Bill's frustration the lawyer and authorities do not consider there are sufficient grounds so Bill embarks on trying to find the individual himself. Not speaking French he's helped by a local woman, Virginie (Camille Cottin) and he soon bonds with her young daughter. Bill is a gentle man trying to amend for his earlier failures as a father and so is somewhat blind to whether Allison may actually be guilty of not. There are obvious parallels to the Amanda Knox case and the story is clearly influenced by it and, for the most part, the film has some good plot twists but does tip occasionally into some odd storylines. But overall it's an entertaining drama that keeps you watching but don't expect a gritty action film because this is not that it's a story of relationships caught in extraordinary circumstances.
2 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
Worth a watch if you're a Matt Damon fan.
- Stillwater review by NL
More of a drama than a thriller but Matt Damon is fantastic as per usual. It had a slow start as I was expecting more of a thriller so not as exciting as I imagined but a very enjoyable movie.
2 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
Okie redneck meets French chic
- Stillwater review by RCO
The initial background scene setting in Stillwater is brief and confusing - it helps to have read the synopsis to know what is going on at the start.
Once we get to Marseille it settles down and finds its pace. The culture clash is not overplayed as Bill settles in to a new life. The twist at the end is nicely handled (if predictable).
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Slow but good
- Stillwater review by CS
Took a while to warm up but found this movie quite entertaining. Good acting from all parties with a good story line
to match. Well worth a watch.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Excellent performances by Damon & Cottin lifts a potentially mediocre drama
- Stillwater review by TB
After the disappointment of his performance in The Last Duel, Matt Damon has more than made up for it in this powerful and extremely watchable drama. His performance and transformation into a “roughneck” father who is desperately trying to help his daughter and get her out of prison is totally believable. I really enjoyed the performance, as well as the very profound curve that his character goes through. There is also no sanitization of the more challenging parts of his role, no hiding of the profound issues that he had trying to raise his daughter and the way that he before kept constantly letting her down and straining every sinew now to try and make it right, whatever the cost.
The chemistry with Camille Cottin is also excellent, as well as with her daughter. Abigail Breslin has the more challenging of the supporting actor’s roles, in that it is in many ways clichéd, but there is some fresh perspectives in its representation.
Tom McCarthy, who made the incredible Spotlight, again shows the level of talent he has not only as a screenwriter, but also director. Scenes are brilliantly staged, and the locations great too. It is definitely not a side of France which is picture-perfect but shows the reality of the difficulty so many people have to live in.
Finally, without giving anything away, I most loved that there was not a “neat, perfect” ending. The whole film had been showing so clearly that, in reality these situations don’t resolve themselves how we would want them to. And it leaves you with questions, as well as looking at, if you'd been in that situation, how you'd have handled it, which is what any good film should do.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.